595,948 views since Jan 12, 2017

Ulema & Javed Ahmad Ghamidi: A Clash of Traditional Narrative and Counter Narrative of Deen Question Answer Q&A
**Topics of discussions:------------------------------
* What authority you have as deeni scholar? you are not from madarsa? your looks also not like a traditional scholar.
* What you have red in Arabic grammer which is compulsory for deen
* What you have red in fiqh? from where you have taken your deeni tabeer?
* What hadees books you have red
* From where you have learned Quran
* What have you red in philosophy and how you are rationalizing deen.
----
* What you want to do with deen, you want to invent new things in deen? You create your own principle to understand deen, who gave you this right?
* You want to understand deen in your own perspective.
* Since 1400 yrs only you are able to understand, all other groups are standing against you.
* You are creating a new firqa and creating fitna
* When you lecture, you say with all certainty, that only your point is correct.
* On what certainty you say all such sweeping statements that Quran isse khali hai, hadees isse khali hai...
------
* You always make changes in your book, how someone can follow you.
* Deen cannot change, other field of knowledge can change, you are moving from taqleed towards takhreeb, you are creating confusion in basics of deen.
* Is deen also ilm?
* What argument you have for the source of deen.
* From hadees you dot take any aqeeda or amal of deen?
* You are a Hypocrite, when you says the source of deen is Prophet muhammad but you do not take his hadees.
* Do you believe in Taqdeer? this is mentioned in hadees not in Quran. Belief in taqdeer is one of the basic of imaan as per hadees e Jibreel
------
* Azam ka fitna, on 7 Qirat of Quran? You believe in Tawattur, then why not 7 Qirat.
* Allama Suyuti and Imam Badaruddin have different opinion than you.
* You doubt on the protection of Quran. Where they read the other Qirat isn't that Quran?
* Abdullah ibn Masood's ravayat that Quran revealed in 7 huroof
* Raavi of Qiraat e amma is also azmi
* Anyone else also declined akhbaare ahaad other than farahi school?
* When the continuity of Quran's status broke?
-----------
* Islamic state, would have given you very high punishment, you have different translation of Quran, Surah Ikhlas and Surah Alaa
* You do not stick to your own created principle, you take a different approach from well known meaning of Arabic words.
* You criticize taqleed and you yourself follow your school of thought fully.
* You have a difference of opinion just for the sake of having a difference.
---------
* Your 25/30 yrs analysis is different from 1400 yrs of Islamic traditions, why only you got this knowledge.
* You understand Islamic knowledge on Daleel, was not this the case of earlier scholars?
* You think of yourself big, other scholar were more humble than to adopt a different approach.
* You challenge 'wahy' and did other scholars were not having intellect and only Farahi school got this wisdom.
* you are creating fitna, this is all your rational thoughts and you contest wahy with this, challenge wahy by your aql??
* You are opening door for everyone to have his own view and daleel
* We should present quran rather than daleel/intellect
* You dont believe but try to understand deen & wahy
* You believe half and reject half as per your convenience
-----------

* You defined sunnah in a new way, you use words different from its well known meanings.
* Why number of Sunnah changes in your analysis, if something is definite, why there is not a definite count of it in your lectures
----------
* Why Ghamidi Sb, have harsh views on some Sahaba, accusing them of Fasaad fil Ardh.
* Ghamidi Sb you have different views on Haz 'Isa Alaihissalaam' coming back to world, opposite to Quran and Hadees.
------------
* You say, we cannot call anybody Mushrik or Kafir, it is beyond humans to declare such, any individual or a group.
------
* You say only 4 things in food is haram, how is it?
* You are very liberal in issues related to haya, and woman and man meeting etiquette
* your people are not visible in favor of Muslims
* your talks and books, does not increase khashiat in me


Al-Mawrid Website: http://www.al-mawrid.org
Al-Mawrid Hind Website: http://www.almawridindia.org
E-Mail: [email protected], [email protected]
Facebook:   / almawridhind  
Subscribe:    / almawridhind  
Twitter:   / almawridindia  
Instagram:   / almawridhindfoundation  

Key Words:
Islam
Quran
Allah
Hadith
Muhammad
Javed Ahmad Ghamidi


#Islam #JavedAhmadGhamidi